Legal notice | About this site | Contact | Search
български (bg)čeština (cs)dansk (da)Deutsch (de)eesti keel (et)ελληνικά (el)English (en)español (es)français (fr)Gaeilge (ga)italiano (it)latviešu valoda (lv)lietuvių kalba (lt)magyar (hu)Malti (mt)Nederlands (nl)polski (pl)português (pt)română (ro)slovenčina (sk)slovenščina (sl)suomi (fi)svenska (sv)català (ca)Democracy - Dialogue – DebateEUROPA > Debate Europe > ForumHome
Climate change and energy Future of Europe Intercultural dialogue Miscellaneous
FAQ Search Memberlist Usergroups
Profile You have no new messages Log out [ toughmeggi ]
Do you think sanctions should be applied against Georgia?
Goto page Previous 1, 2, 3 ... , 10, 11, 12 Next
Debate Europe Forum Index -> Future of Europe
View previous topic :: View next topic
Do you think sanctions should be applied against Georgia from the E.U?
Yes
75% [ 25 ]
No
24% [ 8 ]
Total Votes : 33
Author Message
jim evans
Joined: 11 Mar 2008
Posts: 2648
Location: REPUBLIC OF MORRIS MINOR
Posted: Thu Sep 04, 2008 12:47 am Post subject: Re: NATO cannot replace the UN or corrupt the EU
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cat Whatever wrote:
The stance of the EU on the Georgian invasion of S. Ossetia could make a grown man cry. Sarkozy/Merkel etc. well know that the aggressor here was Georgia and it's CEOs, Dick and George. So why are they acting contrary to the truth and villifying Russia?
Could it be the Nabucco Project? The BTC? By allowing NATO to upstage mandates of the UN, the EU is undermining the best, though terribly flawed, international institution we have to enforce the rule of law. If NATO decides what politics it will pursue, contradicting the UN, we may as well dissolve the ideological justification of peace through cooperation on which the EU is based. The EU has just become the cat's paw of the USA by punishing Russia, for Georgia's war crimes and stupidity.
If the EU is to survive, it must disassociate itself and its policies from NATO. Or alternatively, espouse the USA doctrine of 'might makes right'. Putin will have to talk to Washington DC in its dealing with the
EU.
I don't want to be an American. And I don't want the EU to kow-tow to their imperialistic brand of capitalism. If the EU does not have the ability to provide leaders that represent the views of its citizens, then the union be dammed. Europeans must refuse to be the political tools of the 'masters of the universe' club.
Hear hear CW.
Back to top
B Wilson
Joined: 12 Aug 2008
Posts: 60
Location: España
Posted: Thu Sep 04, 2008 1:18 am Post subject: Re: NATO cannot replace the UN or corrupt the EU
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cat Whatever wrote:
If the EU does not have the ability to provide leaders that represent the views of its citizens, then the union be dammed.
I guess the EU is damned then.
So much for sanctions against anyone.
Maybe they ought to sanction themselves for being colossal hypocrites.
Back to top
Makruha
Joined: 20 Aug 2008
Posts: 85
Location: Russia
Posted: Thu Sep 04, 2008 10:58 pm Post subject:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Nicaragua recognizes South Ossetia and Abkhazia
http://en.rian.ru/world/20080904/116538071.htmlSo the following countries recognized already:
-Russia
-Venezuela
-Nicaragua
I know that Belarus is going to recognize. It's exactly.
Back to top
chris
Joined: 20 Feb 2008
Posts: 3420
Location: Dublin
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2008 1:05 am Post subject:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Makruha wrote:
Nicaragua recognizes South Ossetia and Abkhazia
http://en.rian.ru/world/20080904/116538071.htmlSo the following countries recognized already:
-Russia
-Venezuela
-Nicaragua
I know that Belarus is going to recognize. It's exactly.
hahahaa...i find it funny....some countries have recognised kossovo and some not,depending how bent over to USA are....others have recognised south ossetia and abkhazia and others not,depending how bent over to russia are......i find it a childish game,but played by dangerous fully armed adult politicians and it is dangerous as ridiculous and idiotic......so simple and so complicated in the same time......but it won't end nicelly for anyone......half of the world slaps the other half on the cheek,then the others retaliate and do exactly the same......hope we'll end up with just red cheeks from the slaping and not with anything worse than that......
Back to top
ESLaPorte
Joined: 03 Sep 2008
Posts: 14
Location: Great Lakes- USA
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2008 1:21 am Post subject:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JackTorino wrote:
Georgia is a sovereign Country. We have not recognized South Ossetia as a sovereign Country. Georgia has done military operations in its own territory, for re-establishing full sovereignty on part of it, just like how many EU member countries would do with secessionist territories.
Have we the right to interfere with the internal issues of another sovereign country?
This is a key question we should answer before making such decisions.
Georgia launched its military offensive after to "regain constitutional control." Irregardless if this is "Georgian territories," the wanton shelling of civilian areas is a violation of the Geneva Conventions.
Do we have the right to interfere with the internal affairs of another sovereign country?
Well - we sure did when it came to what Slobodan Milosevic was doing down in his "troubled province" of Kosovo....
Back to top
toughmeggi
Joined: 01 Sep 2008
Posts: 26
Location: brooklyn,ny
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2008 4:19 am Post subject: where were you all when...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
where were you all when russian occupants poisoned and killed with spades on april 9,1989 in capital city of georgia peaceful civilians standing with patriarch and demanding independence, where were you when russian occupants with separatist abkhazians killed thousands of ethnic georgians on their own territory, when 500000 ethnic georgians left their homes with children just the way they were in one outfit and tried to rescue themselves through the mountains [abkhazia] in winter [with little babies] delaying the way to survive, russians were chasing them and after brutal torture would shot them,[ just because they wanted independence, to leave on their own] from russian vandals[because russians always wanted georgian territories, that's how they care about people] , there are so many pictures of brutallity, children were killed in front of mothers eyes , than from the dead child one eye was removed and put into mothers mouth, she fell down lost her consciousness, some people died of cold and were frozen and who was able to hide from russian army came down to different places[to relatives , friends, most of them were homeless living at the dormitory type of places given by the goverment]...this is georgian territory andfor instance, if someone comes to your place and will turn you out of your own place because that person wants that for him/herself, would attack you, would kill you rape you what would you do? where were you even now when ethnic georgians were discriminated, killed one by one in so called ''south osetia'' before this happened, how much more the country can take...Georgia is a small nation and needed a help to join the NATO to deal with this situation. in april 2008 in bucharest ukraine and gergia were denied to join NATO , because it was not in russia's interest and democratic Europe failed to do so because they made themselves heavily dependent on russia's gas...Georgia wants their territories, they will never give up, even if whole world denies it, because those lands georgians have for thousands of years, through centuries from their ancestors...by the way georgians had published books in 5th century, when russians were tribes , as a country russians established actually from 15th century , capital city of georgia counts over 1500y and that was not the first one, originally the capital city before this was different , georgians had heroic history of withstanding multiple muslim attacks, regardless country always had their kings, queens, royalties...later for the last 2 centuries russians took over and now a new era of calamities started for georgians...i wanted to let everybody know that an intelligent part of the world, who knows a bit of the truth, history of this situation would stand up for georgian nation...the ignorance is not a sin, but some people intentionally siding bundit putin who has over 30bln dollars[ did he collect his savings from the salary?] engaging themselves in propaganda ... hoping God will do the justice soon
Back to top
vanvan
Joined: 17 Aug 2008
Posts: 19
Location: Fresno, CA, US
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2008 4:32 am Post subject: Re: where were you all when...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
toughmeggi wrote:
counts over 1500y and that was not the first one, originally the capital city before this was different
Well then if it's all about tenure, I guess you New Yorkers (and Dutch New Amsterdamers) need to give it all back to the Mohawks and the Delawares since you've been there less than 500 years. And our nation is less than 300 years old so I guess we should start the paperwork for returning the whole thing to the Indians. BTW, this poster/shirt is really popular on the West coast. Do you guys have a New York version of it?
Back to top
toughmeggi
Joined: 01 Sep 2008
Posts: 26
Location: brooklyn,ny
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2008 5:38 am Post subject: well, georgia if go back so far as you want...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
georgia in 12-14 century was art least 3 times bigger than it is now, those undebated territories they lost to persians , turkey and others, for instance the part of turkey- trapizon [if you know that ], up to north erzerum, and many others were taken from this country centuries ago, like yourself, however -up to north west sochi and tuapse [you must know that olimpic games suppose to be there if it will be in 2014], belonged to georgians and was taken by russian communists as a gift from georgia in 1924 when they invaded with their troops country and annexed it.but they don't stop here, they want eradication of whole georgians and entire territory...so what can they do, to be the scapegoats for the sake of the peace on the world? but russia will not stop here, they now want ukraine back, poland, [they will soon be provoking separatism between armenia and azerbaijan because of nagorno- karabakh] whole east europe and actually to conrol whole world in 21 century , trying to draw the new map of the world...so would you feel better if georgians would be put into reservations, so they actually are, so many territories are already taken...well, this the story , this attack was well preplaned by russian imperialist, now who will be the next
Back to top
palkonec
Joined: 19 Feb 2008
Posts: 1414
Location: Preßburg
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2008 9:09 am Post subject: Re: well, georgia if go back so far as you want...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
toughmeggi wrote:
georgia in 12-14 century was art least 3 times bigger than it is now, those undebated territories they lost to persians , turkey and others, for instance the part of turkey- trapizon [if you know that ], up to north erzerum, and many others were taken from this country centuries ago, like yourself, however -up to north west sochi and tuapse [you must know that olimpic games suppose to be there if it will be in 2014], belonged to georgians and was taken by russian communists as a gift from georgia in 1924 when they invaded with their troops country and annexed it.but they don't stop here, they want eradication of whole georgians and entire territory...so what can they do, to be the scapegoats for the sake of the peace on the world? but russia will not stop here, they now want ukraine back, poland, [they will soon be provoking separatism between armenia and azerbaijan because of nagorno- karabakh] whole east europe and actually to conrol whole world in 21 century , trying to draw the new map of the world...so would you feel better if georgians would be put into reservations, so they actually are, so many territories are already taken...well, this the story , this attack was well preplaned by russian imperialist, now who will be the next
It isn´t argument. Slovakia was in 9 cemtury so called Great Moravia and covered territory of 1/3 contemporary European Union
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_MoraviaShould we nowadays those territory to claim back
Back to top
Makruha
Joined: 20 Aug 2008
Posts: 85
Location: Russia
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2008 9:55 am Post subject:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CSTO backs Russia's actions in S.Ossetia, condemns Georgia. Foreign ministers from the members of the Collective Security Treaty Organization blasted Thursday Georgia's attack on breakaway South Ossetia and supported Russia's contribution to peace in the region.
http://en.rian.ru/world/20080904/116549751.htmlBack to top
DarunArcheos
Joined: 02 Apr 2008
Posts: 1200
Location: București, România
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2008 10:03 am Post subject: Re: Do you think sanctions should be applied against Georgia
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
spand wrote:
Should the E.U apply sanctions against Georgia at least until their "president" is replaced?
NO !
The EU should not be involved in this.
Georgia is a free independant country and no other nation or organism should have the right to pressure this country to change its internal politics.
The president is elected through vote, by the people - it is their right and their fortune or misfortune to have the president they have elected.
Back to top
Makruha
Joined: 20 Aug 2008
Posts: 85
Location: Russia
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2008 10:08 am Post subject:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Israel says stopped arms supplies to Georgia prior to conflict. Israel imposed an embargo on arms supplies to Tbilisi a week before Georgia attacked its breakaway region of South Ossetia, the Israeli ambassador to Russia said on Thursday.
http://en.rian.ru/world/20080904/116547799.htmlBack to top
moroshan
Joined: 10 Mar 2008
Posts: 202
Location: Maramureş, România
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2008 10:32 am Post subject:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Makruha wrote:
Israel says stopped arms supplies to Georgia prior to conflict. Israel imposed an embargo on arms supplies to Tbilisi a week before Georgia attacked its breakaway region of South Ossetia, the Israeli ambassador to Russia said on Thursday.
http://en.rian.ru/world/20080904/116547799.htmlHmmm, than Israel knew something
Back to top
panther
Joined: 03 Feb 2008
Posts: 5731
Location: Durham England
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2008 10:56 am Post subject: Re: where were you all when...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
vanvan wrote:
toughmeggi wrote:
counts over 1500y and that was not the first one, originally the capital city before this was different
Well then if it's all about tenure, I guess you New Yorkers (and Dutch New Amsterdamers) need to give it all back to the Mohawks and the Delawares since you've been there less than 500 years. And our nation is less than 300 years old so I guess we should start the paperwork for returning the whole thing to the Indians. BTW, this poster/shirt is really popular on the West coast. Do you guys have a New York version of it?
How ! vanvan, well said and welcome to the forum !!
Back to top
Crafts
Joined: 29 Apr 2008
Posts: 2524
Location: Athens, Ex Ottoman Province of Greece
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2008 11:22 am Post subject:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Of course Israel knew something!!
I mean, isn't it already an established truth that Israel knows all? I'm not kidding, these reported Mossad failures in the past 10 years or so must be just a smokescreen.
Now about Georgia.
After the first Iraq war a series of restrictions were imposed on the Hussein regime, such as a no fly zone and an arms embargo. Since Gerogia was the instigator of the recent conflict in the Caucasus, I think it is only reasonable if similar measures were taken, only with a different flavour this time.
That is, instead of doing it through the Security council, a more comprehensive peace agreement should be brokered by international agents that would entail such measures.
I understand that the politicians in the West are either allied or warm towards Georgia as a country (it has been established that its President is uncool by now) but Georgia has to sustain some sort of demilitarization.
This is something we can sell to the Ruskies as a cookie for allowing an international force under the auspices of the U.N. to assume control of the new de facto states. Like Kosovo, for example. There is nothing else we can do to persuade or coerce them to remove all Russian army from Georgia. Talk is cheap and Medvedev seems to be hearing impaired in respect to all "calls" from the West.
And it would all be to Georgia's benefit. Something that is not mentioned is that with the seccession of Abkhazia, Georgia loses about half of its coastline. And the Black Sea region countries are definitely in need of their coastal regions, it is a matter of survival considering most of the global trade is taking place through the sea.
It is in the interest of Europe to be a catalyst in reversing failed policies such as the arbitrary creation of mini states, upholding the international law principle of inviolability of borders. And not just because the law needs to be upheld or because Russia has to be stopped. It is just a pretty bad way to waste resources and money. Bosnia-Herzegovina and Kosovo come to mind as the proverbial barrel of the Danaids (no bottom) when it comes to wasted money....
Back to top
Display posts from previous: All Posts1 Day7 Days2 Weeks1 Month3 Months6 Months1 Year Oldest FirstNewest First
Debate Europe Forum Index -> Future of Europe All times are GMT + 2 Hours
Goto page Previous 1, 2, 3 ... , 10, 11, 12 Next
Page 11 of 12
Stop watching this topic
Jump to: Select a forum Какъв Европейски съюз желаете? (bg)----------------Климатични промени и енергияБъдещето на ЕвропаМеждукултурен диалогРазни Fòrum de debat europeu (ca)----------------Canvi climàtic i energiaEl futur d’EuropaDiàleg interculturalMiscel•lània Jakou Evropskou unii byste si přáli? (cs)----------------Změna klimatu a energetikaBudoucnost EvropyMezikulturní dialogRůzné Hvilket EU ønsker du? (da)----------------Klimaændringer og energiEU's fremtidInterkulturel dialogDiverse Wie soll die Europäische Union nach Ihrer Vorstellung aussehen? (de)----------------Klimawandel und EnergieZukunft EuropasInterkultureller DialogVerschiedenes Milline peaks olema Euroopa Liit? (et)----------------Kliimamuutus ja energeetikaEuroopa tulevikKultuuridevaheline dialoogMuud teemad Ποια Ευρωπαϊκή Ένωση επιθυμείτε; (el)----------------Αλλαγή του κλίματος και ενέργειαΜέλλον της ΕυρώπηςΔιαπολιτισμικός διάλογοςΔιάφορα θέματα What sort of European Union do you want? (en)----------------Climate change and energyFuture of EuropeIntercultural dialogueMiscellaneous ¿Cuál es la Unión Europea que usted quiere? (es)----------------Cambio climático y energíaFuturo de EuropaDiálogo interculturalVarios Quelle Union européenne souhaitez-vous? (fr)----------------Changement climatique et énergieAvenir de l'EuropeDialogue interculturelDivers Cén saghas Aontais Eorpaigh ar mhaith leat? (ga)----------------An t-athrú aeráide agus fuinneamhTodhchaí na hEorpaComhphlé IdirchultúrthaIlghnéitheach Come vorreste che fosse l'Unione europea? (it)----------------Cambiamenti climatici ed energiaFuturo dell’EuropaDialogo interculturaleVarie Kādai, Jūsuprāt, jābūt Eiropas Savienībai? (lv)----------------Klimata pārmaiņas un enerģijaEiropas nākotneStarpkultūru dialogsDažādi Kokios Europos norite? (lt)----------------Klimato kaita ir energijaEuropos ateitisKultūrų dialogasĮvairūs Ön milyen Európai Uniót szeretne? (hu)----------------Éghajlatváltozás és energiafelhasználásEurópa jövőjeKultúrák közötti párbeszédEgyéb témák X’tip ta’ Unjoni Ewropea trid? (mt)----------------Tibdil klimatiku u enerġijaIl-ġejjieni ta’ l-EwropaDjalogu interkulturaliOħrajn Wat voor een Europese Unie wilt u? (nl)----------------Klimaatverandering en energieToekomst van EuropaInterculturele dialoogDiverse onderwerpen Jakiej Unii Europejskiej chcemy? (pl)----------------Zmiany klimatyczne i energiaPrzyszłość EuropyDialog międzykulturowyRóżne tematy Que União Europeia quer? (pt)----------------Alterações climáticas e energiaO futuro da EuropaDiálogo interculturalVários Ce fel de Uniune Europeană vă doriţi? (ro)----------------Schimbările climatice şi energiaViitorul EuropeiDialog interculturalDiverse Akú Európsku úniu by ste chceli? (sk)----------------Zmeny klímy a energiaBudúcnosť EurópyMedzikultúrny dialógRôzne Kakšno Evropsko unijo si želite? (sl)----------------Podnebne spremembe in energijaPrihodnost EvropeMedkulturni dialogRazna vprašanja Minkälaisen Euroopan unionin sinä haluat? (fi)----------------Ilmastonmuutos ja energiaEU:n tulevaisuusKulttuurien kanssakäyminenMuut aiheet Vilket slags EU vill vi ha? (sv)----------------Klimatförändring och energiEU:s framtidInterkulturell dialogÖvriga ämnen
You can post new topics in this forum
You can reply to topics in this forum
You can edit your posts in this forum
You can delete your posts in this forum
You can vote in polls in this forum
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
Legal noticeAbout this siteContactTop of the page